Pigeon Forge restaurants range from farm-to-table, local eateries to fast food and everything in between. Come hungry and stay for the food! On our recent visit, we were excited to try a few of the most popular places and found their reputations well-deserved.

Best Restaurants in Pigeon Forge

The Local Goat

While there are plenty of Pigeon Forge restaurants that are independent, there aren’t too many that use local and sustainable foods and make everything from scratch. The Local Goat is a farm-to-table craft restaurant and bar that prides itself on finding locally sourced foods.

Everything in their kitchen is homemade, including the amazing fresh bread, right down to the hamburger buns! With craft cocktails and a fine wine list, The Local Goat offers something for everyone in your party.

A gin-based cocktail in a coupe glass with a sprig of rosemary at the Local Goat, a favorite of Pigeon Forge restaurants.

If it’s warm, sit on the outdoor covered patio and enjoy the beautiful mountain views. And if it’s cold, try to claim a seat near the indoor fireplace—or just grab a seat at the bar, which is our favorite way to dine if it’s just the two of us.

The menu changes seasonally, but if available, try the Fried Green Tomatoes with bacon jam and caramelized onions. Bacon Jam. That is a thing.

Pigeon Forge restaurants include Local Goat where they offer this plate of fried green tomatoes with bacon jam and goat cheese on top.

And there are these Strawberry Sriracha Honey Wings that are not to be missed—a sweet heat version of wings that will tantalize your taste buds from start to finish.

A plate of strawberry sriracha wings from Local Goat.

Have you ever tried Deep Fried Deviled Eggs? I’ve had some that were unimpressive, but the ones at The Local Goat are top-notch. They start with excellent quality free-range eggs, then lightly bread the egg white portion with panko crumbs and deep fry it. Then the fried egg white is stuffed with creamy deviled egg and garnished with candied bacon, sriracha, and chopped green onions. It is divine.

You may also like…
Pigeon Forge Attractionsall the fun things you can do while you’re in Pigeon Forge!

Now, let’s talk dessert. All the Pigeon Forge restaurants offer splendid desserts. Ice cream shops, candy shops, bakeries—you can find them all. But if you’re looking for something a little more special, The Local Goat is your place.

A dish of creme brulee from the Local Goat with a cocktail glass in the background.

If a restaurant has creme brulee on the menu, I have to try it and theirs was perfect. In a shallow dish, so you get good crispy caramelization in every bite, creamy vanilla custard, and just a sprinkle of powdered sugar on top. Yes, please!

But you don’t want to miss the White Chocolate Bread Pudding either! Maybe you should order one of everything.

The Pottery House Cafe and Grill

There are plenty of Pigeon Forge restaurants right in the downtown area, which is littered with fun shops and cafes, and one of the most notable is the inviting Pottery House Cafe. Grab some friends and dine al fresco in the lovely outdoor courtyard while koi swim nearby in a small pond complete with a waterfall.

The outdoor courtyard at the Pottery House Cafe one of the best Pigeon Forge restaurants.

Here, you must try the crispy homemade potato chips topped with melted cheddar jack cheese, bacon bits, scallions, and sour cream. Oh. My. Goodness. These chips are served with a delightful homemade avocado ranch dressing for dipping. Just sit back and loosen your belt and dig in.

A plate of loaded homemade potato chips from the Pottery House Cafe.

Since you’ve feasted on those homemade loaded potato chips, you might want to go a little lighter for your actual lunch and just have some wonderful Tomato Basil Soup.

Or loosen your belt a little more and have the Pimento Cheese BLT—Fried green tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and pimento cheese served on grilled sourdough bread with steak fries. Um, YES!

A slice of Peanut butter pie on a plate from Pottery House Cafe, one of the best restaurants in Pigeon Forge.

Before you head out to walk around downtown, be sure you get a slice of the famous Pottery House Peanut Butter Pie. Creamy luscious peanut butter filling over a crumbly shortbread crust, drizzled with chocolate. This is not to be missed. Pinky Promise.

Where to Eat in Pigeon Forge

Bennett’s Barbecue

Barbecue is a mainstay at several Pigeon Forge restaurants—you are in the South, after all, and we love our barbecue! So if you’re in Tennessee, barbecue is a must and Bennett’s is some of the best.

The ribs are fall-off-the-bone tender and juicy and the servings are generous with the favorite barbecue sides to choose from.

A plate of ribs, fries, slaw, and biscuit from Bennett's BBQ in Pigeon Forge.

The coleslaw has just the right amount of creaminess and the baked beans are delicious.

If you order a combo platter, you can get a few ribs and Bennett’s famous Burnt Ends, a genius way to use the top portion of brisket that leaves your mouth watering for more.

Bullfish Grill

When you need a place for dinner that will make adults and kids happy, stop in at the Bullfish Grill in Pigeon Forge. The large dining area and full bar means that you’ll have plenty of room for a big group and excellent service to keep your glasses filled.

The large dining area in the Bullfish Grill in Pigeon Forge.

Try the Beer Cheese Dip or the huge thick-cut Onion Rings here and get ready for your taste buds to dance a happy jig. The wine list here is prime, with Sonoma Cutrer and Cakebread Chardonnay, two of my favorites!

For your dinner selections, try the Grilled Atlantic Salmon or the Cilantro Lime Grilled Shrimp. And for the little ones, you can choose good old standbys of fried shrimp or a burger.

More Pigeon Forge Restaurants

Old Mill Restaurant Pigeon Forge

The old water wheel in the river outside the Old Mill Restaurant in Pigeon Forge.

One of the most famous of Pigeon Forge restaurants, and attached to the Old Mill Pigeon Forge, is the Old Mill Restaurant, a multi-story affair that offers a wide variety of menu items.

The restaurant is known for its Southern food and the dining room overlooks the Little Pigeon River with some pretty views.

A plate of eggs, grits, and ham on a table that looks out to the river in Pigeon Forge at the Old Mill Restaurant.

The Old Mill Restaurant Pigeon Forge is a great way to begin the day with a hearty breakfast. You’ll get a little basket of biscuits and muffins, then you can move on to stone-ground grits that were ground right next door, along with cooked-to-order eggs, pancakes, sausage and gravy, bacon, and much more!

A basket of muffins from the Old Mill Restaurant in Pigeon Forge.

If you drop by for lunch or dinner, you’ll find old Southern favorites like country-fried steak, sugar-cured ham, pot roast and gravy, chicken and dumplings, chicken potpie, and much more.

All entrees come with the delicious corn chowder and fresh vegetables and sides served family style—and of course they offer homemade desserts.

The restaurant is famous for their pecan pies which are baked from scratch daily and are available to take home.

This is a small sampling of the amazing food to be found at some of the Pigeon Forge restaurants. Be sure to visit MyPigeonForge.com for information on many, many more Pigeon Forge restaurants and cafes, as well as all the amazing attractions in Pigeon Forge.

Special thanks to the Pigeon Forge Department of Tourism who sponsored this post so I could experience these wonderful Pigeon Forge restaurants. All opinions are my own. 

Check out my travel guide to restaurants on Amelia Island, Florida, and Chicago Restaurant Guide

Lucy standing behind a counter with a cheese board and glass of wine.

About the author

Hi, I’m Lucy! I’m a home cook, writer, food and wine fanatic, and recipe developer. I’ve created and tested hundreds of recipes so that I can bring you the best tried and true favorites.

Follow Lucy on social media:

You May Also Like:

Sign up with your email address to receive a 5-day series of Southern Cooking Secrets, followed by weekly emails with recipes and tips. We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *