Skip to Content

Donna's Italian Beef

Slow-roasted beef with pepperoncinis and dark beer. Super easy recipe that makes tender, braised beef for a crowd!

Italian beef with pepperoncinis

There are many variations of Italian beef out there, most claiming to originate in Chicago. My Chicago friend Donna's version is slow-roasted for many hours and my other favorite is one that is cooked just slightly and then left to rest in the garlicy juices overnight.

But Donna's is by far the easiest, especially when you're expecting a crowd.

You throw everything in a slow-cooker or a roasting pan and cook on low heat for several hours. Either way, everything goes in at the same time and then you leave it alone until it's done. No chopping, no stirring, no work. What's better than that?!

Start with a quality beef roast, like an eye of round. Place it in the slow-cooker or a large roasting pan, then add a jar of pepperocinis with juice, one bottle of dark beer, one packet of Good Seasonings Italian dressing mix and ½-1 can of beef consomme.

Putting roast and peppers in crockpot.

Wrap tightly with foil if using a roasting pan. If using slow-cooker, set to low and cook for 8-10 hours and if roasting in the oven, cook at 250 overnight or for 8-10 hours. Then just shred the beef and leave it in the juices until ready to serve.

Serve on hard, crusty rolls so the juice can soak into the rolls. We throw in a salad and some roasted potatoes and call it a meal!

Or use it for tacos and top with these easy Pickled Red onions! This is great for potluck dinners or tailgating. Enjoy!

Donna's Italian Beef

5 from 1 vote
save to your free collection
A super easy, spicy beef recipe to feed a crowd. It's robust and perfect for tailgating.
save print pin
prep time: 10 mins
total time :10 hrs 10 mins
servings :12 servings
author: Lucy Brewer


  • 1 beef roast, (eye of round preferred)
  • 1 large jar of pepperoncinis
  • 1 bottle dark beer
  • 1 packet Good Seasonings Italian dressing mix
  • ½-1 can beef consomme


  • Place roast and all ingredients in roasting pan.
  • Cover tightly with foil.
  • Cook overnight (or 8-10 hours) at 250.
  • Shred the beef and let rest in the juices until ready to serve.
  • Serve on a hard roll with juices soaked into the bun.
Click here to save this recipe to your Pinterest board!
Serving: 12servingsCalories: 349kcalProtein: 36gSaturated Fat: 9gCholesterol: 130mgSodium: 200mg
love this recipe?share on Instagram and tag @southernfoodandfun!
Recipe Rating