Southern Thanksgiving Secrets: From Turkey to Pie

Southern Thanksgiving secrets mostly come down to timing: what gets done the Sunday before, what gets done Wednesday night, and what waits for Thursday. For most of my life, my family gathered at my Granny’s house for Thanksgiving, and now I’m the one hosting. Here’s what I’ve learned about getting the whole meal to the table hot and on time.

Start the turkey on Sunday

A frozen turkey takes days to thaw in the refrigerator, about 24 hours for every 4 to 5 pounds. If you’re brining, add another day for the brine plus an overnight rest uncovered in the fridge so the skin dries out. My rule of thumb puts a 20-pound turkey in the refrigerator, thawing, by the Thursday before Thanksgiving. My guide to thawing and roasting turkey has the timelines by weight.

Before the turkey goes in, clean out the refrigerator and freezer. Last year’s leftovers can go, and so can any spice more than a year old, because old spices start to lose their flavor. Stock up on containers, too, for make-ahead dishes and for sending leftovers home.

Want to save this post?

Enter your email and we'll send it straight to your inbox.

First nameEmail addressSaveSign up for the newsletter to get new recipes delivered to your inbox.

Trust a thermometer, not the pop-up

I always wet-brine my turkey in a turkey brine with kosher salt and herbs, then rub it all over with herb butter made with fresh herbs before it roasts. Brining seasons the meat all the way through, and the butter crisps the skin.

The other half of a juicy turkey is taking it out on time. A turkey is done at 165 degrees F, measured in the thickest part of the breast and the innermost part of the thigh and wing. Don’t wait on the pop-up timer, because the turkey is often done before it pops, and that’s where dry, stringy turkey comes from. Meat keeps cooking after it leaves the oven, so a reading a few degrees shy of 165 will climb while the bird rests.

Related 📖 ➡️ Using a meat thermometer

Ham belongs on the table, too

For my family, Thanksgiving isn’t complete without a baked ham beside the turkey. A bourbon-glazed ham with orange sauce needs little more than its glaze and time in the oven, so it’s an easy second main dish when the guest list grows.

Southern Thanksgiving dressing, not stuffing

In the South, it’s dressing, and it bakes in its own dish. I don’t stuff a turkey, whatever the cooking method. My Granny made cornbread dressing with celery, onion, and sage every year, and it’s still the dish we wait all year for.

Bake a pan of buttermilk cornbread with no sugar a day ahead, crumble it with a few leftover biscuits or some torn white bread, and let the crumbs dry overnight. Pour in the stock a little at a time. The mixture should look almost soupy before it goes in the oven, so it bakes up moist instead of dry. Taste it and season it early, since you can’t fix the seasoning once it’s baked. I mix mine the day before and bake it just before dinner.

Gravy and two cranberry sauces

Gravy is not optional at a Southern Thanksgiving. My giblet gravy, finished with cream, goes over the turkey and the dressing. For cranberry sauce, we always set out the jellied kind from the can, and I serve fresh cranberry sauce with orange zest beside it for anyone who wants something brighter.

Schedule the oven before the day

If you have one oven, write down the temperature and bake time for every dish on your menu, then work out what can share the oven and what has to go in first. The turkey has to rest before it’s carved anyway, and that window is when the casseroles go in.

Most casseroles can be assembled a day ahead. Hold back any cracker or breadcrumb topping until right before baking, or it turns soggy in the fridge and never crisps. My tips for Southern sides and salads cover more make-ahead habits that work at Thanksgiving.

Some sides are non-negotiable. Any other time of year we’ll have roasted green beans, but at Thanksgiving it has to be old-fashioned green beans cooked with bacon. And there would be a revolt in my house without baked mac and cheese with no eggs.

Bake the desserts days ahead

Pies and pound cakes are the easiest part of the meal to get out of the way early. Pecan pie, fudge pie, pumpkin pie, and cream cheese pound cake can all be made a couple of days ahead, and they travel without a mess.

I make a Southern pecan pie with cane syrup, swapping it in for some of the corn syrup for a deeper flavor. Nobody makes sweet potato pie like my Mama, so I follow my Mama’s Southern sweet potato pie to the letter. An old-fashioned cream cheese pound cake keeps for days and still slices clean on Thursday. No matter how much turkey and dressing I’ve eaten, I fix a sampler dessert plate with a little taste of everything!

Make room for the people

Thanksgiving is a long meal, so set a table that’s easy to talk across. Keep flower arrangements short, and skip the appetizers or keep them light, since there’s already so much food coming. Mismatched serving dishes are fine. The people around the table are the point, not the place settings.

One tradition at our house is a thankful tablecloth everyone signs each year with waterproof markers. We leave it on the table through the holidays, and reading the old notes brings back people who aren’t at the table anymore. Start one this year, and your family will have its own record of every Thanksgiving to come.

When you’re ready to plan the meal itself, my Southern Thanksgiving menu from turkey to pie has every dish we serve, and these 36 make-ahead Thanksgiving recipes help you clear the stove before Thursday.